Shopping notes for wide and narrow feet

Late afternoon is the honest hour for shoes. Feet tend to lengthen and spread after a day of standing, and a pair that felt polite at breakfast can pinch by dinner. The brown leather derbies at the top of this essay, one with broguing and one with a plain toe, are a useful picture of the problem. Two shoes can share a color and a lace-up front and still sit differently on the same foot, because the last under the leather is not the same shape.

Width is a letter and a last. The letter is what the size run prints. The last is the form the shoe was built around. Brands do not share one standard, and a letter that feels right in a sneaker can be useless in a pointed heel. Shop for the sensation at the ball of the foot and at the heel, then check whether the size run you are looking at even includes widths.

Pinch, slip, and overflow

Pinch at the ball of the foot is the clearest narrow signal. The ball is the widest part of the forefoot, just behind the toes. If that spot burns, if the little toe is pressed against the side, or if you see a bulge of foot over the edge of the sole, the shoe is too narrow there. Going up a full length to escape the pinch often leaves the heel swimming. Length and width are different measurements. Fix the one that is actually failing.

Slip has more than one cause. A heel that lifts while the ball feels fine may be too long, the heel cup may be cut for a narrower heel than yours, or the whole shoe may be so wide that the foot slides forward. Overflow is the opposite: the upper cannot cover the foot. Name which of the three you feel before you ask for a different size. A longer shoe will not cure overflow. A wider letter will not cure a heel cup that is simply the wrong shape.

Try shoes later in the day, with the socks you actually wear. A thin dress sock hides a problem that a heavier cotton sock will announce. Stand, do not only sit. Walk a short line inside the shop, or across the room if you are at home. The shoe should hold the heel without biting the ball.

Width letters are not universal

Letters such as B, D, E, and 2E are labels inside one maker's system. Another maker may use the same letter for a different amount of room, or may skip widths and cut everything on a single last. A chart that prints one number and no letter is a length, sometimes with a last you can only discover by trying the shoe.

Do not convert a letter from one brand and expect the next brand to honor it. Write down the letter that worked, the style name, and what your foot felt. If a site lets you filter by width, use the filter, then still read the product page. Check whether the size run includes widths for the exact shoe, rather than assuming the whole shop is organized around them.

The blue floral heels below are a reminder that a pretty upper can hide a narrow last. The flower print is not the fit. The pointed toe and the pump shape are.

What you feel	Likely cause	What to try next
Pinch or burn at the ball	Last or width too narrow across the forefoot	A wider letter on a similar last, tried later in the day
Toes crowded in a point	Toe shape, not only the width letter	A rounder toe, even in a letter you already know
Heel lifts, ball feels fine	Length, a loose counter, or a wide heel cup	A shorter length, or a last with a closer heel
Foot spills over the sole	The foot is wider than the sole	A wider last, not a longer size
Pressure on the instep	A low vamp or a stiff tongue	Laces you can loosen, or a different last

Last shape

A last is the three-dimensional form around which the upper is pulled. A wide last usually adds room at the ball and sometimes through the instep. It does not automatically add a roomy toe, and it does not automatically tighten the heel. Some wide lasts are simply a standard shape with a bit more girth. Others are cut from the start for a foot that spreads. You learn which is which by putting the shoe on, not by trusting the adjective in the title.

A narrow last can feel secure on a narrow heel and still crush a wider forefoot. A single letter that changes the whole shoe at once serves that foot poorly. Look for an adjustable closure, a lace or a buckle, so you can hold the heel without clamping the ball. A derby, like the pair in the hero photograph, opens at the laces in a way a pump cannot.

The beige and white low-tops in the next photograph are lace-up sneakers. Laces let you tighten the instep and leave the toe box alone, which is why a sneaker and a pointed heel are not the same fitting problem. If the toe box is tapered, the laces cannot give your toes back the space the pattern removed.

Heels and a narrow heel cup

The floral pair is a pointed-toe heel, one shoe standing and one raised on a plinth. The point funnels the toes toward the center. No width letter fully undoes a sharp tip. If your toes are already cramped in a round-toe flat, a pointed heel in the same letter will be worse. Look for a point that stays wide past the ball, if you want that shape at all.

The heel cup of a pump is a different mechanism from a sneaker. A sneaker holds the foot with laces and a padded collar. A pump holds the foot with a close heel and the tension of the upper. A narrow heel may feel gripped by a pump and lost in a roomy sneaker. A wide heel may find that the cup bites, or that sizing up lets the foot slide forward until the toes hit the point. Wear does not move a toe box out of the way. If the cup rubs the heel bone on the first walk, it will not become kind later. The floral print is display. Fit is what the shoe does when your weight is in it.

How to shop the size run

Start from the letter and the last you already understand. If you pinch, try a wider letter before a longer length. If you slip at the heel in a shoe that fits the ball, try a shorter length or a different last. "I need a wide" is incomplete. Wide where?

Check whether the size run includes widths for that style. A homepage can look broad while the shoe you want exists in one width only. Read the width line on the style itself. Try the widths the page actually lists, later in the day, and keep a short record: brand, style, length, width letter, and whether the ball, the toes, or the heel failed.

• Name pinch, slip, or overflow before you change a size.
• Try the shoe later in the day, in the socks you wear.
• Read the width on that style, not only on the brand.
• Do not treat a pointed toe as the same problem as a lace-up.
• Stand and walk a few steps. A seated fit hides heel slip.
• Write down the letter that worked, and start the next brand fresh.

When you are ready to see a live size run, use the retailer's own page and read the widths printed there.

Open the DSW homepageLeaves Rive Gauche Style for the DSW homepage. This placeholder is not an affiliate link.

DSW sets its assortment and its policies, and this journal does not.